How to Conduct a Comprehensive Patent Search Before Filing

Before submitting a patent application, conducting a thorough patent search is a crucial step that can help avoid legal complications and ensure that your invention is novel. A patent search allows you to determine whether your invention has already been patented or if a similar idea exists, which could potentially affect your patent's chances of approval. This blog walks you through the importance of a patent search, how to perform one effectively, and why it's essential for your patent application process.

Why Conduct a Patent Search?

A patent search serves as the foundation of your intellectual property (IP) strategy. It involves reviewing existing patents, patent applications, and published patent literature to assess whether your invention is novel and non-obvious. Here are a few key reasons why conducting a comprehensive patent search is essential:

  1. Avoid Infringement: Conducting a search helps ensure that your invention doesn’t infringe on existing patents. This can save you time, money, and legal headaches in the long run.
  2. Improve Patent Quality: A thorough patent search allows you to refine your invention and strengthen your application by identifying prior art (existing patents and publications) that might be similar to your idea. This allows you to differentiate your invention or tweak its features to ensure it's novel.
  3. Increase the Chances of Approval: When you file for a patent, the patent office will conduct its own search to determine if your invention is novel and non-obvious. Performing your own search beforehand can help you assess your chances of receiving a patent and avoid unnecessary rejections
  4. Save Time and Money: Patent applications can be costly, and rejections or revisions can add to the expense. By performing a patent search first, you may uncover potential roadblocks early, enabling you to adjust your strategy before spending on filing and legal fees
  5. Identify Market Opportunities: A patent search also reveals patents that may be expired or in the public domain. These patents can provide insights into areas where you can capitalize on existing technology and introduce innovative products or services.

Steps to Conduct a Patent Search

A comprehensive patent search involves more than simply Googling an invention. It requires searching through patent databases, understanding legal terminology, and evaluating the results based on patent law standards. Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you perform a thorough search:

1. Identify Keywords and Concepts

The first step in any patent search is to define the key concepts of your invention. Think about the essential features of your idea and identify terms and keywords related to it. Include both technical terms and common phrases that describe your invention.

For example, if your invention is a type of eco-friendly packaging, your keywords could include terms like “biodegradable packaging,” “sustainable packaging,” “compostable,” and “eco-friendly materials.” The more precise and varied your keyword list, the better your chances of finding relevant patents.

2. Search Patent Databases

Once you have your keywords, the next step is to search patent databases. Several databases allow you to search through existing patents and pending patent applications. Some of the most commonly used databases include:

3. Use Classification Codes

Patent offices assign classification codes to patents to categorize inventions into specific fields or technologies. Searching by classification codes can help you locate relevant patents more efficiently.

For example, the USPTO uses the Cooperative Patent Classification (CPC) system to categorize patents based on their technological fields. If you’re working on a medical device, you can search using the relevant CPC code related to medical technology

By using these codes, you can narrow your search to find patents in specific technological areas. This helps you avoid sifting through unrelated patents that aren’t relevant to your invention.

image

4. Review Patent Claims

When you find a patent that appears similar to your invention, it's important to carefully review the claims. Patent claims define the scope of the invention and what the patent covers. Even if the patent description seems similar, the claims may reveal important distinctions.

Focus on the independent claims, which outline the core invention, and compare them with the features of your invention. If your idea is substantially different from the claims in the patent, your invention may still be patentable

5. Evaluate the Patent’s Legal Status

Once you’ve identified potentially relevant patents, check their legal status. Some patents may have expired, while others may still be in force. For example, if a similar patent has expired, you may be able to use the technology or build upon it without infringing on an active patent

You can check the legal status of a patent on databases like the USPTO’s Public PAIR system or WIPO’s PATENTSCOPE.

6. Seek Professional Assistance

Conducting a comprehensive patent search can be complex, especially when dealing with numerous databases and legal terminology. If you're unsure or don’t have the time to perform an in-depth search, you may want to consider hiring a professional patent search firm or a patent attorney. These experts have the knowledge and tools to conduct thorough searches and interpret the results accurately

What to Do After the Patent Search

Once you’ve completed your search, analyze the results carefully. If your invention is unique and doesn’t conflict with existing patents, you may proceed with filing your patent application. However, if you find similar patents, you may need to adjust your invention or the way you present it in the application to ensure that it meets the criteria for patentability.

You may also consider filing a provisional patent application, which allows you to secure a filing date while continuing to refine your invention. This can be a useful option if you need more time to finalize your invention or conduct further searches.

Conclusion: The Importance of a Patent Search Before Filing

A comprehensive patent search is an essential part of the patent application process. It helps ensure that your invention is unique, protects your intellectual property, and minimizes the risk of patent infringement. By conducting a thorough search, you can increase the likelihood of patent approval, avoid legal challenges, and enhance the value of your invention. Whether you conduct the search yourself or enlist the help of professionals, taking the time to conduct a patent search before filing is a critical step in securing the protection you need for your innovation.